EXERCISE
FOR PEOPLE WITH DIABETES
Tiffany
Cowen; halfmoon@ufl.edu;
Undergraduate Student, University of Florida
Diabetes is a disease that is associated
with the hormone insulin.
Insulin is secreted by the pancreas
following meals, and is required for
uptake of glucose
to be used in cells.
There are two types of diabetes: Type
I and Type II. Type I diabetes is least
common, and is due to the inability
of the pancreas to produce insulin.
This type of diabetes is usually present
from birth, and requires insulin injections
and/or pills. Type II is far more common,
and therefore will be the focus of this
paper.
Type II diabetes is also known as adult-onset
diabetes, since most people develop
this type as adults, as opposed to type
I, which is acquired around birth. People
with type II diabetes experience insulin
resistance, and because of this
their bodies are unable to respond to,
and use, the available blood glucose.
Glucose is an essential source of fuel
for the body, as all carbohydrates are
broken down into these basic building
blocks. As a result, the cells of people
with diabetes are essentially starving,
and over time this can lead to eye,
kidney, nerve, and heart damage. Diabetes
is most common in African Americans,
Latinos, Native Americans, and Asian
Americans/Pacific Islanders, as well
as the aged population, although this
disease is not restricted to those populations.
(1)
According to a major government study
- the Diabetes Prevention Program (DPP)
- regular exercise has been shown to
delay, and in some cases, prevent the
onset of Type II Diabetes. (2) In fact,
in one study, the overall incidence
of diabetes in people with impaired
glucose tolerance was reduced by 58%
with positive lifestyle changes. (3)
These positive lifestyle changes focused
on improving cardiovascular fitness
and muscular strength, as well as physical
activity in general.
“Large cohort studies have found
that higher levels of habitual aerobic
fitness, and/or physical activity, are
associated with significantly lower
subsequent cardiovascular and overall
mortality, to a much greater extent
than could be explained by glucose lowering
alone.”(4) It is also known that
exercise increases insulin sensitivity.
Insulin sensitivity is a measure of
how well the cells respond to and uses
the available blood glucose. This is
important for those with diabetes to
consider as a way to manage this disease.
Before beginning any exercise program,
it is important that a doctor be consulted.
Considering which medications the patient
is currently taking, and the proper
types of exercise for that patient is
essential. It is recommended that people
with diabetes live a general physically
active lifestyle, as well as engage
in aerobic exercise, strength training,
and regular stretching.(2) It should
be stated that physical activity is
defined as bodily movement produced
by the contraction of skeletal muscle
that requires energy expenditure in
excess of resting energy expenditure.
Exercise is defined as a subset of physical
activity: planned, structured, and repetitive
bodily movement performed to improve
or maintain one or more components of
physical fitness. The terms "physical
activity" and "exercise"
are often used interchangeably. Lastly,
physical fitness is defined as including
cardio-respiratory fitness, muscular
fitness, and flexibility.(4)
Approximately 54.8% of adults diagnosed
with diabetes are obese.(5) Since many
people with type II diabetes are overweight
or obese, this type of exercise is beneficial
because there is less load on the joints,
thereby enabling an enjoyable experience
that the person is more likely to stick
with. If the person with diabetes experiences
lower limb numbness, aquatic exercise
may be a better alternative. If the
person chooses other forms of exercise,
they must be sure to pay special care
to the condition of their feet, and
any blisters or sores that may form,
since a major concern for people with
diabetes is poor circulation. In addition,
any kind of exercise that raises blood
pressure is likely not the best option
for someone with type II diabetes. This
includes lifting heavy weights or performing
static, or isometric, exercises.
After it is determined that the patient
is ready to engage in a regular exercise
routine, there are several options as
to what types, the duration, and the
intensity of exercise for that individual.
According to the U.S. Surgeon General’s
report, it is prescribed that people
with diabetes live an active lifestyle
by, for example, using the stairs instead
of the elevator, parking their car further
from their destination, and minimizing
sedentary activities such as watching
television. In addition, it is recommended
that people with type II diabetes exercise
for a minimum of 30 minutes a day, approximately
three to five days per week. The effect
of increased insulin sensitivity following
exercise lasts for approximately 72
hours. Therefore, people with type II
diabetes should not allow more than
two consecutive days to pass without
exercising. There is evidence that resistance
training results in an increased period
of insulin sensitivity following exercise,
possibly due to the increased muscle
mass. (4)
In one study, the greatest effect of
exercise on HbA1c
was seen with the highest exercise intensity
(6). HbA1c is a test performed on people
with diabetes in order to determine
their blood glucose levels for the previous
two to three months. In this study,
subjects exercised at 75% of their VO2
max with some intervals at even
higher intensity, for 55 minutes three
times a week, including five minutes
of warm-up and five minutes of cool
down.
There are several types of exercise
for people with type II diabetes. When
considering aerobic activity, walking,
running, bicycling, and swimming are
traditional and effective options. Although,
if the person is obese, overweight,
or experiences peripheral
neuropathy, these types of aerobic
activity may be limiting. As mentioned
earlier, aquatic exercise is an alternative
that many find to be advantageous. Water
allows the person to feel lighter and
more buoyant, and therefore this may
make it easier for someone who is obese
or overweight to gain similar benefits.
The overall goal is to elevate heart
rate and recruit large muscle groups.
Strength training may produce faster
changes in body composition and functional
status due to the gains in muscle mass.(4)
This is more rewarding to the client
and will improve their motivation, which
is a critical factor is determining
their adherence to the program. “With
increased age, there is a tendency to
progressive declines in muscle mass,
leading to "sarcopenia,"
decreased functional capacity, decreased
resting metabolic rate, increased adiposity,
and increased insulin resistance, and
resistance training can have a major
positive impact on each of these.”(4)
Stretching has been shown to increase
range of motion and reduce the risk
of injury, although there is some controversy
as to whether it helps with metabolic
control.(4)
There are certain situations when exercise
should be avoided for a person with
diabetes. One example is if hyperglycemia,
or high blood glucose, occurs. The American
Diabetes Association recommends that
exercise be avoided if fasting glucose
levels are >250 mg/dl and ketosis
is present, and performed with caution
if glucose levels are >300 mg/dl
even if no ketosis is present.(4) In
comparison to hyperglycemia, hypoglycemia,
or low blood glucose, should also be
considered before exercising. Exercise
can cause hypoglycemia due to increased
need for fuel, which is more of a concern
during prolonged exercise. Medication
dose and carbohydrate consumption should
be considered, as these levels may need
to be modified when an exercise routine
is added. In addition, certain medications
including diuretics,
ß-blockers,
ACE
inhibitors, aspirin,
and lipid-lowering
agents are often taken by those with
diabetes. These medications may hinder
the person’s exercise capacity,
so proper attention should be paid to
these interactions.
It is now clear that exercise has great
benefits for people with type II diabetes.
A doctor should always be consulted
before beginning any exercise program,
as there are certain considerations
to take when prescribing the proper
exercise routine. Even still, there
are multiple types of exercise options
for people with diabetes to engage in.
The main types of exercise to include
in a routine are aerobic, strength,
stretching, and an overall active lifestyle.
Reference List:
- American Diabetes Association.
Retrieved March 21, 2009, Web site:
http://www.diabetes.org/home.jsp
- U.S. Department of Health and Human
Services, What I need to know about
Physical Activity and Diabetes. Retrieved
March 22, 2009, from http://diabetes.niddk.nih.gov.lp.hscl.ufl.edu/dm/pubs/physical_ez/physactivity.pdf
- Tuomilehto, Jaakko (May 3, 2001).
Prevention of type 2 diabetes mellitus
by changes in lifestyle among subjects
with impaired glucose tolerance. The
New England Journal of Medicine,
344, Retrieved March 22, 2009, from
http://content.nejm.org/cgi/content/full/344/18/1343
- Sigal, Ronald (2004). Physical
activity/exercise and type 2 diabetes.
Diabetes Care, 27, Retrieved March
22, 2009, from http://care.diabetesjournals.org/cgi/content/full/27/10/2518#R121
- (November 19, 2004). Prevalence
of overweight and obesity among adults
with diagnosed diabetes --- United
States, 1988--1994 and 1999--2002.
Center for Disease Control,
53, Retrieved March 22, 2009, from
http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm5345a2.htm
- Mourier, A (1997). Mobilization
of visceral adipose tissue related
to the improvement in insulin sensitivity
in response to physical training in
NIDDM. Effects of branched-chain amino
acid supplements.Diabetes Care,
20, Retrieved March 22, 2009,
from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/9051392
|